The first tooth set of Ptychodus atcoensis (Elasmobranchii: Ptychodontidae), from the Cretaceous of Venezuela
Swiss Journal of Palaeontology volume 132, pages 69–75 (2013)
Ptychodus atcoensis is a characteristic Late Cretaceous durophagous shark, with a fossil record that was previously known exclusively from the Coniacian Atco Formation in Texas, USA, North America. We illustrate and describe for the first time a partial articulated tooth set of P. atcoensis, from the Cretaceous of the Venezuelan Andes, representing the only known record of this species outside of North America, thus significantly increasing the palaeobiogeographic distribution of this taxon. This partial tooth set also documents characteristic variation in the teeth of P. atcoensis that will allow isolated teeth of the species to be more readily identified and located in the dentition.
The genus Ptychodus Agassiz 1835, refers to a characteristic group of Upper Cretaceous sharks, with a chronostratigraphic distribution ranging from the Albian to the Campanian (Welton and Farish 1993; Johnson et al. 2002; Cappetta 2012). The distinctive characteristics of the genus Ptychodus teeth with a massive and strong crown adapted for crushing, suggesting that these sharks had a durophagous diet based on molluscs (see e.g., Kauffman 1972; Cappetta 2012). The geographical distribution of the genus Ptychodus during the Late Cretaceous was global, currently known from a little over 20 fossil species with records in Africa, North America and South America, Asia, Australia and Europe (MacLeod 1982; Williamson et al. 1989, 1991; Welton and Farish 1993; Antunes and Cappetta 2002; Brito and Janvier 2002; Mutter et al. 2005; Alvarado-Ortega et al. 2006; Blanco-Pinion et al. 2007; Hamm and Cicimurri 2011; Carrillo 2009; Underwood and Cumbaa 2010; Verma et al. 2012; Cappetta 2012; Carrillo-Briceño 2012a). The systematic position of Ptychodus is still highly uncertain. Characters like the dental morphology, the pavement pattern of the dentition and the presence of calcified vertebrae led many authors to suggest the inclusion of these sharks within Neoselachii (Maisey et al. 2004) or in specific groups like the Myliobatidae (Woodward 1889; Leriche 1902; Romer 1945), hybodontiformes (Welton and Farish 1993; Cappetta 2012) or Heterodontiformes (Müller 2008). Ptychodus atcoensis Hamm 2009 is the most recently described species of Ptychodus, and so far, known only from the Coniacian Atco Formation of north-central Texas in the United States of America. Here, we describe and illustrate a partial articulated tooth set of P. atcoensis from Cretaceous rocks of the Andes in Venezuela (Fig. 1), which was first illustrated by Aguilera (2010) as Ptychodus sp. This is the first record of P. atcoensis outside of Texas and thus palaeobiogeographic implications of this new record are discussed.
Materials and methods
In this study, we examined a piece of an articulated tooth set of P. atcoensis, for which the only existing locality data indicate the fossil came from Cretaceous rocks of the Andes in Venezuela, specifically in the Andes of Merida, but the geological formation and the exact location of the find are not recorded. This specimen is deposited in the Paleontology Collection of the Archaeological Museum Gonzalo Rincón Gutiérrez, Universidad de Los Andes, Mérida, with a repository code CU-010. This articulated tooth set is represented by 44 teeth, some of which are fractured and only preserve the marginal part of the crown. The tooth set is included in a single block with a very indurated limestone matrix, and it is curved in the anterior section, which is due to taphonomic processes that affected fossilization; this does not allow the specimen to be observed in its entirety in occlusal view, as seen in other dentitions known for Ptychodus (see e.g., Shimada 2012). The taxonomic description and descriptive terminology have been adopted from Cappetta (2012), and the comparative material used for this study is located at the Shuler Museum of Paleontology, Southern Methodist University, Dallas, Texas (SMU).
Class Chondrichthyes Huxley 1880
Order incertae sedis
Family Ptychodontidae Jaekel 1898
Genus Ptychodus Agassiz 1835
1974 Ptychodus sp.; Meyer, p. 71–72.
1993 Ptychodus sp.; Welton and Farish: p. 70.
2009 Ptychodus atcoensis; Hamm: p. 63–65, Figs. 10 and 11.
2010 Ptychodus sp. Aguilera: p. 11.
2011 Ptychodus atcoensis Hamm and Cicimurri: p. 110, Fig. 3b.
Hamm and Cicimurri (2011) claimed to propose the name P. atcoensis as a new species, noting that Hamm (2009) had already published the name in volume 8 of the Occasional Papers of the Dallas Paleontological Society. They state (Hamm and Cicimurri 2011, p. 111) that “because this volume of occasional paper was not distributed through a publication house, according to ICZN code 8 regarding the dissemination of works where new taxa are named, herein we establish the taxon P. atcoensis.” However, our reading of Article 8 (especially 8.1) of the ICZN indicates that Hamm (2009) does meet the criteria of publication of the ICZN. Therefore, we attribute the species name P. atcoensis to Hamm (2009), not to Hamm and Cicimurri (2011).
The tooth set (CU-010) belongs to a lower jaw and is composed of a symphyseal tooth file, a tooth file on the left side and three tooth files on the right side. The symphyseal tooth file is composed of 14 teeth, and these are the largest amongst the complete teeth of the tooth set; the largest specimen is 24 mm in length mesio-distally, 18 mm in width labio-lingually, and the crown is 20 mm high measured from the base of the enameloid. These teeth are symmetrical and nearly square in outline with tall central cusps with high and bulbous crowns where strong ridges oriented mesio-distally converge towards the apexes of the crowns to create a distinctive chevron pattern. These ridges are thick at the base and thin at the apex, creating a cutting edge, which is maintained from the apex of the crown to the marginal area of the tooth. The marginal area is fully ornamented by concentric ridges and a strongly granular texture. The labial rim of the crown is convex and constitutes the point of articulation (articular facet) to the lingual face of a tooth located immediately labially. The lingual rim is concave with a shallow depression at the base of the crown for an articulation with the margin of the labial rim of the tooth positioned immediately lingually. The mesio-distal margins are wide and rounded.
The first lateral tooth file at the left and right side of the tooth set (CU-010) has 9 and 12 teeth, respectively, and the second tooth file of the right side only has 3 complete teeth and 3 left marginal crown fragments. At the right side of the tooth set, there is a third tooth file; however, this only has 3 left marginal parts of the crowns.
All these lateral teeth have an asymmetrical shape, with a crown more rounded and a central cusp canted (or offset) laterally. Ridges on the central cusp tend to converge toward the crown center but do not cross the crown as transverse ridges. The marginal area is fully ornamented by concentric ridges and a strongly granular texture, and at the lingual rim there is a shallow depression at the base of the crown, for an articulation (articular facet) with the margin of the labial rim of the tooth positioned immediately lingually. The basal section of all teeth is covered by (encased in) the limestone matrix, and for this reason the root features cannot observed.
Species included in the genus Ptychodus can be differentiated on the basis of differences in dental morphology. According to Hamm and Shimada (2004), the main criterion for the identification of species within Ptychodus is the determination of distinctive features such as the crown height, configuration and number of ridges present in the crown and the ornamentation of the marginal area. P. atcoensis was known previously from the Coniacian of Texas, USA, for more than 25 years before the species was formally named by Hamm (2009). This very distinctive species is a high-crowned Ptychodus most readily recognized by the chevron-shaped transverse ridges on the cusp apices (Welton and Farish 1993; Shimada et al. 2009; Hamm 2009; Hamm and Cicimurri 2011). According to Hamm and Cicimurri (2011), the dental morphology of Ptychodus anonymus Williston 1900 and Ptychodus mammillaris Agassiz 1835, which bears a similarity to P. atcoensis, can be clearly distinguished due to the characteristic chevron pattern present in P. atcoensis, among the diagnostic features that can also be used to differentiate this taxon from other species of the genus Ptychodus (Hamm 2009; Hamm and Cicimurri, 2011).
Meyer (1974) suggested that P. atcoensis is a taxon transitional between P. anonymus and Ptychodus mortoni Mantell 1839. However, the suggestion of Meyer (1974) is not be likely given that P. anonymus has a Cenomanian–Turonian range (Welton and Farish 1993), and P. mortoni ranges from the early Turonian to the Campanian (Shimada 2012), both species older than P. atcoensis, which is probably restricted to the Coniacian of North and South America.
The morphological pattern of P. atcoensis has been recognized as similar to the pattern present in ptychodontid species, especially those with high crowns and radial ridges, such as P. mortoni, Ptychodus cyclodontis Mutter et al. 2005, and Ptychodus sp. described by Brito and Janvier (2002) and Carrillo (2009). P. mortoni has a heterodont dentition and its teeth have more conical crowns with a pattern of ridges radiating from the apex of the crown to the marginal area (Cappetta 2012; Shimada 2012) that differs from P. atcoensis, which presents a more rounded crown and a characteristic pattern of chevron-shaped ridges. P. cyclodontis was described from the Turonian of Cuba on the basis of a partial tooth plate and its dentition consists of teeth characterized by a high, robust conical crown with radial ridges (Mutter et al. 2005). The dental morphology of P. cyclodontis is closely similar to that of Ptychodus sp. described by Brito and Janvier (2002), from the Turonian of Colombia or Venezuela; both taxa are homodont and can be considered conspecific (Mutter et al. 2005). The teeth of Ptychodus sp. described by Carrillo (2009) from the Cenomanian–Santonian (?) of Venezuela has an exceptional high conical cusp, a morphology that differs from P. cyclodontis and P. mortoni, but it is similar to P. cyclodontis in that it possesses a limited area in each tooth crown (Shimada 2012). Teeth of P. atcoensis possess more marginal area than the teeth of P. cyclodontis and Ptychodus sp. described by Carrillo (2009) (Shimada 2012). According to Shimada et al. (2009), whether or not the four Ptychodus species with radial ridges known at this time (P. atcoensis, P. cyclodontis, P. mortoni, and Ptychodus sp. described by Carrillo (2009)) constitute a monophyletic lineage cannot be ascertained because of the poor knowledge on some of the taxa.
Like other tooth sets of Ptychodus, the P. atcoensis tooth set from Venezuela is characterized by a symphyseal tooth file of relatively large teeth flanked by lateral tooth files of somewhat smaller teeth. Comparison with other illustrated tooth sets of Ptychodus (Woodward 1904; Williamson et al. 1991, Fig. 2; Hamm 2009, Figs. 4, 6, 8, 14; Shimada et al. 2009, Figs. 1, 2, 7; Shimada 2012, Figs. 1–5) reveals that the Venezuelan tooth set is part of the lower dentition, preserving the symphyseal tooth file flanked by lateral tooth files near the center of the mouth. Variation in the Venezuelan tooth set is characteristic of that seen in other tooth sets of Ptychodus: teeth of the symphyseal tooth file are more symmetrical and higher crowned than teeth of the lateral tooth files (see e.g., Hamm 2009; Shimada 2012). The high angle (about 90°) between the central cusp and flanking platform (relatively flat or sloping marginal area of the crown) is characteristic of the symphyseal tooth file in P. atcoensis, and these are robust and the largest teeth in the lower jaw, whereas the tooth sizes in successive lateral tooth files gradually decrease.
Previously, only isolated teeth of P. atcoensis were found at the base of the Coniacian Atco Formation (Austin Group) in Texas (Meyer 1974; Welton and Farish 1993; Hamm 2009; Hamm and Cicimurri 2011), which restricted their distribution to North America. The presence of P. atcoensis in the Cretaceous of Venezuela increases the palaeogeographic distribution of this taxon, but leaves a vacuum in terms of age, because there is no detailed record of the provenance of the Venezuelan specimen. The only Upper Cretaceous geologic units of the Andes of Venezuela of Coniacian age are La Luna Formation (Cenomanian–Campanian), with a wide distribution in the Mérida Andes (Cordillera de Mérida) and Sierra de Perija (Fig. 1), and the Navay Formation (Coniacian–Maastrichtian), restricted to the southeastern flank of the Cordillera de Mérida (La Marca 1997). La Luna Formation is a unit with abundant vertebrate fossils (see Carrillo-Briceño 2012b), especially of fish, which includes the presence of Ptychodus decurrens Agassiz 1838, P. mortoni and P. sp. (Brito and Janvier 2002; Carrillo 2009; Aguilera 2010; Carrillo-Briceño 2012a). Given that the only previous record of P. atcoensis is of Coniacian age in North America, its Venezuelan record also could be inferred of Coniacian age with a possible source from La Luna Formation. However, no information about the geological formation and the exact location of the find are recorded.
Other records of Ptychodus from the Upper Cretaceous of South America include P. whipplei Marcou 1858, of the Itamaracá Formation, Brazil (Silva 2007), and P. chappelli from Colombia and Ecuador (Reinhart 1951; Wenz 1972). However, P. chappelli is likely an invalid species because its teeth are very similar to teeth of P. mammillaris. Relatively little is known of the distribution of Ptychodus species in the Gondwana continents during the Cretaceous, However, the record reported here and a recent record of P. decurrens from the Cretaceous of India (Verma et al. 2012) indicate a relatively cosmopolitan distribution of at least some Ptychodus species in seaways of both the northern and southern hemispheres. To test this idea, more records of Ptychodus need to be documented from South America, like that reported here, and from the other continents that made up Cretaceous Gondwana.
Based on comparisons between the CU-010 specimen, illustrated earlier by Aguilera (2010) as Ptychodus sp., and fossil material of P. atcoensis from the Coniacian Atco Formation in North America, we can confirm taxonomic allocation of the tooth set CU-010 to P. atcoensis. The specimen CU-010, though incomplete, is the only known record of a set of the articulated dentition of P. atcoensis and thus enables a clearer understanding of the morphology and pattern of dental articulation of this taxon. There is a lack of precise data on the geological unit and locality from which the specimen CU-010 was collected, leaving a void in terms of age and current knowledge of the chronostratigraphic range of P. atcoensis. However, its presence in the Upper Cretaceous of Venezuela significantly increases the palaeobiogeographic distribution of this taxon, as it represents the only known record of the species outside North America.
Agassiz, L. (1835). Kritische Revision der in der Ittiolitoiogin Veronese abgebildeten fossilen Fische. Neues Jahrbuch für Mineralogie, Geognosie, Geologie und Petrefaktenkunde, pp. 290–316.
Aguilera, O. (2010). Peces Fósiles del Caribe de Venezuela. Washington, DC: Gorham Printing.
Alvarado-Ortega, J., Garibay-Romero, L. M., Blanco-Piñon, A., González-Barba, G., Vega-Vera, F. J., & Centeno-García, E. (2006). Los peces fósiles de la Formación Mexcala (Cretácico Superior) en el Estado de Guerrero, México. Revista Brasileira de Paleontología, 9(3), 261–272.
Antunes, M. T., & Cappetta, H. (2002). Sélaciens du Crétacé (Albién-Maastrichtien) d’Angola. Palaeontographica, Abtheilung A, 264, 85–146.
Blanco-Pinion, A., Garibay-Romero, L., & Alvarado-Ortega, J. (2007). The oldest stratigraphic record of the Late Cretaceous shark Ptychodus mortoni Agassiz, from Vallecillo, Nuevo Leon, northeastern Mexico. Revista Mexicana de Ciencias Geológicas, 24(1), 25–30.
Brito, P. M., & Janvier, P. (2002). A ptychodontid (Chondrichthyes, Elasmobranchii) from the Upper Cretaceous of South America. Geodiversitas, 24(4), 785–790.
Cappetta, H. (2012). Chondrichthyes II: Mesozoic and Cenozoic Elasmobranchii: Teeth. In H.-P. Schultze (Ed.), Handbook of Paleoichthyology (Vol. 3E). München: Gustav Fischer Verlag.
Carrillo, J. (2009). Presencia del genero Ptychodus (Elasmobranchii: Ptychodontiade) en el Cretácico superior de los Andes de Trujillo Venezuela. Geominas, 37(50), 207–210.
Carrillo-Briceño, J. (2012a). Presencia de Ptychodus mortoni (Elasmobranchii: Ptychodontidae) en el Cretácico Superior de Venezuela. Revista Geológica de América Central, 46, 145–150.
Carrillo-Briceño, J. (2012b). El Cretácico Marino y su fauna de Vertebrados. In M. R. Sánchez-Villagra (Ed.), Venezuela Paleontológica: Evolución de la diversidad en el pasado (pp. 119–132). St. Gallen: Printwork Art GmbH.
Garrity, C. P., Hackley, P. C., & Urbani, P. F. (2010). Digital shaded relief map of Venezuela (v.20): US Geological Survey Open-File Report 2004-1322. http://pubs.usgs.gov/of/2004/1322/.
Hamm, S. (2009). New data on the occurrence and distribution of Ptychodus from the Upper Cretaceous (Coniacian-Santonian) of Texas. Dallas Paleontological Society Occasional Papers, 8, 48–77.
Hamm, S. A., & Cicimurri, D. J. (2011). Early Coniacian (Late Cretaceous) selachian fauna from the basal Atco Formation, lower Austin Group. North Central Texas. Paludicola, 8(3), 107–127.
Hamm, S., & Shimada, K. (2004). A Late Cretaceous Shark, Ptychodus martini Williston from Texas. The Texas Journal of Science, 56(3), 215–222.
Huxley, T. H. (1880). On the application of the laws of evolution to the arrangement of the Vertebrata and more particularly of the Mammalia. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London, 1880, 649–662.
Jaekel, O. (1898). Die Selachier aus dem oberen Muschel kalk Lothringens. Abhandlungen Geologische Spezialk. Elasass-Lothringen, Series, 3(4), 273–332.
Johnson, S. C., Lucas, S. G., & Friedman, V. (2002). Stratigraphic range and biostratigraphic utility of the Cretaceous shark genus Ptychodus. Geological Society of America, Abstracts with Programs, 34(6), 462.
Kauffman, E. G. (1972). Ptychodus predation upon a Cretaceous Inoceramus. Palaeontology, 15, 439–444.
La Marca, E. (1997). Origen y Evolución Geológica de la Cordillera de Mérida, Venezuela. Mérida: Universidad de Los Andes, Cuadernos Geográficos.
Leriche, M. (1902). Révision de la fauna icthyologique des terrains cretaces du Nord de la France. Annales de la Société Géologique du Nord, 31, 87–155.
MacLeod, N. (1982). The first North American occurrence of the Late Cretaceous elasmobranch Ptychodus rugosus Dixon with comments on the functional morphology of the dentition and dermal denticles. Journal of Paleontology, 56, 403–409.
Maisey, J. G., Naylor, G. J. P., & Ward, D. J. (2004). Mesozoic elasmobranchs, neoselachian phylogeny and the rise of modern elasmobranch diversity. In G. Arratia & A. Tintori (Eds.), Mesozoic fishes 3, systematic, paleoenvironment and biodiversity (pp. 17–56). München: Verlag Dr. Friedrich Pfeil.
Mantell, G. A. (1839). The Wonders of Geology; or, a Familiar Exposition of Geological Phenomena; Being the Substance of a Course of Lectures Delivered at Brighton (3rd ed., Vols. 2). London: Reese and Fletcher.
Marcou, J. (1858). Geology of North America, with two reports on the prairies of Arkansas and Texas, the Rocky Mountains of New Mexico, and the Sierra Nevada of California. Zurcher and Furrer: Originally made for the United States Government. Zürich.
Meyer, R. E. (1974). Late Cretaceous elasmobranchs from the Mississippi and east Texas embayments of the Gulf Coastal Plain. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, Southern Methodist University, Dallas, TX, p. 419.
Müller, A. (2008). Ein artikulierter fund von Ptychodus aus dem Obercenoman von Westfalen. Geologie und Paläontologie in Westfalen, 70, 55–63.
Mutter, R. J., Iturralde-Vinet, M., & Carmona, J. F. (2005). The first Mesozoic Caribbean shark is from the Turonian of Cuba: Ptychodus cyclodontis sp. nov. (? Neoselachii). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 25(4), 976–978.
Reinhart, R. T. (1951). A new shark of the family ptychodontide from South America. University of California Publications, Bulletin of Geological Sciences, 28, 195–202.
Romer, A. S. (1945). Vertebrate Paleontology. Chicago: University of Chicago press.
Shimada, K. (2012). Dentition of late Cretaceous shark, Ptychodus mortoni (Elasmobranchii, Ptychodontidae). Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 32(6), 1271–1284.
Shimada, K., Rigsby, C. K., & Kim, S. H. (2009). Partial skull of Late Cretaceous durophagous shark, Ptychodus occidentalis (Elasmobranchii: Ptychodontidae), from Nebraska, USA. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 29, 336–349.
Silva, M. (2007). Os vertebrados da Bacia da Paraíba: Cretáceo superior-Paleoceno, Nordeste do Brasil. Unpublished Magister Dissertation. Universidad federal of Pernambuco, Brasil, p. 201.
Underwood, C. J., & Cumbaa, S. L. (2010). Chondrichthyans from a Cenomanian (Late Cretaceous) bonebed, Saskatchewan, Canada. Palaeontology, 53, 903–944.
Verma, O., Prasad, G. V. R., Goswami, A., & Parmar, V. (2012). Ptychodus decurrens Agassiz (Elasmobranchii: Ptychodontidae) from the Upper Cretaceous of India. Cretaceous Research, 33, 183–188.
Welton, B. J., & Farish, R. F. (1993). The Collector’s Guide to Fossils Sharks and Rays from the Cretaceous of Texas. Lewisvile, TX: Before time.
Wenz, S. (1972). Présence du Sélacien Ptychodus (P. chappelli) dans le Crétacé supérieur de l’Equateur (Amérique du Sud). Bulletin du Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, 74, 91–94.
Williamson, T. E., Lucas, S. G., & Kirkland, J. I. (1991). The Cretaceous elasmobranch Ptychodus decurrens Agassiz from North America. Geobios, 24, 595–598.
Williamson, T. E., Lucas, S. G., & Pence, R. (1989). Selachians from the Hosta Tongue of the Point Lookout Sandstone (Upper Cretaceous, Santonian), central New Mexico. New Mexico Geological Society, Guidebook, 40, 239–245.
Williston, S. W. (1900). Some fish teeth from the Kansas Cretaceous. Kansas University Quarterly, 9, 27–42.
Woodward, A. S. (1889). Catalogue of the fossil fishes in the British Museum (Part 1, p 474). London: British Museum of Natural History.
Woodward, A. S. (1904). On the Jaws of Ptychodus from the Chalk. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 60, 133–136.
The authors wish to thank Dr. Bruce Welton for information and Dr. Guillaume Guinot for his important collaboration; Dr. Lino Meneses and Mr. Heriberto Monsalve of the Gonzalo Rincón Gutiérrez Museum, Universidad de Los Andes, Merida, Venezuela, for their valuable assistance and approval of the revision of the fossil material. Comments on an earlier version of the manuscript by the reviewers improved its content and clarity.
About this article
Cite this article
Carrillo-Briceño, J.D., Lucas, S.G. The first tooth set of Ptychodus atcoensis (Elasmobranchii: Ptychodontidae), from the Cretaceous of Venezuela. Swiss J Palaeontol 132, 69–75 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13358-013-0053-3